Parade aims to feature only the best products and services. If you buy something via one of our links, we may earn a commission.
Let’s face it: Heels are the perfect accessory. They’re incredibly versatile and stylish, providing a subtle “lift” to the wearer. Plus, they’re a great way to enhance a woman’s self-image and confidence. What’s not to love? One of Old Navy’s newest pair of heels fits this description perfectly. They’re ultra sleek and comfortable. Best of all, they’re similar to Vince Camuto, Zappos and DSW styles almost four times the price.
We’re talking about Old Navy’s Slingback Mary Jane Heels. They’re currently $39.99 and come in three different colors, including silver, “Black Jack” and wine purple. They’re also available in multiple sizes and feature a stylish pointed-toe design. Let’s check them out!
Related: Target Is Selling ‘Beautiful’ $35 Heels That Look So Similar to a Dolce Vita Style That’s Nearly 4x the Price
Slingback Mary Jane Heels, $39.99 at Old Navy
Old Navy
🛒🛒 SIGN UP for our Pop Shop newsletter & get the best deals, problem-solving products & cool finds right in your inbox 🛍️
These Old Navy heels are quite stunning and feature a block heel with a 100% rubber outsole (giving them good traction and slip resistance). In contrast, the inside is comprised of 100% polyester, making them ultra-soft for your feet and toes.
One anonymous reviewer loved how they were “super comfortable and perfect for work.” Due to their unique style, though, it’s safe to say these are perfect for other occasions too, like date nights, fancy dinners and casual outings with friends.
As an added bonus, this particular style features an elastic buckle that fastens at the ankle. With its “over-the-foot” design, you won’t have to worry about them falling off (or slipping) throughout the day.
Related: Target Is Selling the ‘Best Winter Slippers’ for 47% Off, and They Look Just Like an Ugg Style That’s Nearly 7x The Price
Sindree Slingback Pumps, $110 at Vince Camuto
Vince Camuto
As we briefly discussed, these Old Navy heels are quite similar to Sindree Slingback Pumps, which are $110 at Vince Camuto. Like their cheaper counterpart, these heels come in multiple colors and sizes, including “New Silver,” black, chocolate and “Soft Buff.” They also feature a block heel (with a 2.7″ lift), an ankle buckle and a pointed toe.
Despite these similarities, there are some minor differences worth noting. First and foremost, you’ll notice that this particular style lacks the additional strap found on the Old Navy heels. They’re also made from premium nappa leather (instead of rubber), making them ultra-soft to the touch.
Related: Nordstrom Rack Is Selling ‘Comfortable and Cute’ Sorel Boots for Up to 73% Off — Shop Our 5 Favorites Before They’re Gone
Schutz Blanche Mid Heels, $148 at Zappos
Zappos
These Schutz Blanche Mid Heels are also similar, which are $148 at Zappos. Like the Old Navy variety, these heels feature a 3″ block heel, a pointy toe and an adjustable buckle that’s located on the side. This makes them appropriate for casual outings, work or dressy occasions. And while they don’t feature an “over-the-foot” strap, the heels make up for this deficiency with two extra strands on the side (providing additional support to the ankle strap itself).
The biggest difference between these two styles is their materials. In contrast to the Old Navy heels, the Zappos shoes are comprised entirely of leather, which gives them a soft and luxurious feel. It’s also worth noting that only one color is offered (prata silver).
Related: Aldi Is Selling $13 Genuine Suede Slippers Similar to Lands’ End and Eddie Bauer Styles up to Over 5x the Price
BCBG Gillian Mary Jane Pumps, $59.99 (Originally $99) at DSW
DSW
Old Navy’s heels also resemble these BCBG Gillian Mary Jane Pumps, which are $59.99 (originally $99) at DSW. Out of all the shoes on our list, these are probably the closest (in appearance) to the Old Navy version. They come in several sizes and colors, including black, silver metallic and off-white. They also feature a 3″ block heel, an adjustable Mary Jane strap and pointed toes.
Like the Slingback Mary Jane Heels, the BCBG pumps are made of synthetic materials and have a lightly padded footbed/sole. The biggest difference between the two is their finish, as the BCBG pair is slightly shinier than the matte appearance of the Old Navy heels. There’s also a difference in the outer sole, as one is black, while the other is more tan/brown in appearance.
Although you shouldn’t necessarily expect “designer quality” from the Old Navy heels, the similarities between these heels are hard to ignore! If you’re looking for quality heels (at an affordable price), this pair from Old Navy is definitely worth checking out!
Up Next:
Related: Target Is Selling ‘Stylish’ $30 Kitten Heels That Look Just Like a High-End Style That’s Over 34x the Price
