The Natasha Lyonne-led mystery-comedy Poker Face is set to return to Peacock later this year, and with it comes a fresh batch of potential criminals, con artists, and shady characters for Lyonne’s human lie detector, Charlie Cale, to uncover.
🎬 SIGN UP for Parade’s Daily newsletter to get the latest pop culture news & celebrity interviews delivered right to your inbox 🎬
Created by Rian Johnson, Poker Face took audiences by storm with its first season, blending Columbo-style case-of-the-week storytelling with a modern road trip twist. Lyonne’s performance as the scrappy, endlessly curious Charlie was a major highlight (nabbing her an Emmy nomination), as she traveled across America encountering peculiar crimes and eccentric criminals.
While the details of Poker Face Season 2 remain tightly under wraps, fans can expect another set of twisted mysteries, unexpected twists, and an ever-growing rogues’ gallery of guest stars. The first season boasted an impressive lineup that included Adrien Brody, Stephanie Hsu, Tim Meadows, and Judith Light, among others. Now, the second season looks to continue that trend, bringing in an equally exciting mix of Hollywood veterans and surprising names to the series.
Here are all of the guest stars for Poker Face Season 2 we know so far.
Related: The 15 Most Anticipated TV Shows of 2025
Poker Face Season 2 Guest Stars
Cynthia Erivo
A Tony-winning performer for her role in The Color Purple on Broadway, Cynthia Erivo later made a strong transition to film with her Oscar-nominated performance in Harriet and standout roles in Widows and Bad Times at the El Royale. Of course, perhaps most noticeably, she recently played Elphaba in Wicked: Part One, earning her an Oscar nomination.
Giancarlo Esposito
Giancarlo Esposito became widely recognized for his chilling portrayal of Gus Fring in Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul, playing the meticulous and ruthless drug kingpin. His extensive career also includes standout roles in Do the Right Thing and The Mandalorian, where he brings a similar quiet menace to his characters.
John Mulaney
A former Saturday Night Live writer turned stand-up star, John Mulaney has also lent his voice to animation, most notably as Andrew Glouberman on Big Mouth. He has also appeared in Documentary Now! and hosted SNL multiple times.
Katie Holmes
Katie Holmes first rose to fame as Joey Potter on Dawson’s Creek, playing the intelligent and headstrong girl-next-door. She later took on more dramatic roles in films like Batman Begins and The Gift, showcasing her range beyond her teen drama roots.
Haley Joel Osment
Haley Joel Osment gained early fame with his Oscar-nominated performance in The Sixth Sense. He later appeared in A.I. Artificial Intelligence and taking on more comedic and eccentric roles in The Boys and Future Man.
Margo Martindale
A character actress with decades of experience, Margo Martindale won an Emmy for her role as the ruthless Mags Bennett in Justified. She has since played similarly complex roles in The Americans and BoJack Horseman.
Kumail Nanjiani
Kumail Nanjiani made a name for himself in comedy with Silicon Valley, where he played the awkward yet ambitious Dinesh, before transitioning into dramatic roles like his Oscar-nominated screenplay The Big Sick and his superhero debut in Eternals.
B.J. Novak
Best known for playing the opportunistic Ryan Howard on The Office, B.J. Novak has also made a mark as a writer and director, with projects like The Premise and the satirical crime thriller Vengeance, which he wrote, directed, and starred in.
Awkwafina
After breaking out with her comedic roles in Crazy Rich Asians and Ocean’s 8, Awkwafina has since expanded her range with dramatic performances in The Farewell and her semi-autobiographical series Awkwafina Is Nora from Queens.
Carol Kane
Carol Kane first gained recognition with her Oscar-nominated role in Hester Street before becoming a comedy icon with Taxi. She later played the eccentric landlady Lillian Kaushtupper on Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt.
Related: Everything to Know About Poker Face Season 2
Gaby Hoffmann
Gaby Hoffmann began her career as a child actor in films like Now and Then and Uncle Buck, later shifting to independent and prestige television with acclaimed performances in Transparent and Girls.
Richard Kind
A veteran character actor, Richard Kind has been a staple in sitcoms like Mad About You and Spin City, while also lending his distinctive voice to animated films such as Inside Out and appearing in crime comedies like Only Murders in the Building.
Melanie Lynskey
After her debut in Heavenly Creatures, Melanie Lynskey built a career with roles in Two and a Half Men, Yellowjackets, and The Last of Us.
Alia Shawkat
Alia Shawkat made a name for herself as the quick-witted and rebellious Maeby Fünke in Arrested Development, later taking on darker comedic territory as the lead in Search Party, where she played a self-absorbed millennial drawn into a mystery that spirals out of control.
Cliff “Method Man” Smith
Method Man transitioned from his career as a rapper with Wu-Tang Clan into acting, taking on roles in The Wire and Power Book II: Ghost, where he plays a slick and morally ambiguous defense attorney.
Corey Hawkins
After his breakout as Dr. Dre in Straight Outta Compton, Corey Hawkins went on to star in 24: Legacy, showcased his musical talents in In the Heights, and recently took on a dramatic lead role in The Last Voyage of the Demeter.
David Krumholtz
David Krumholtz has had a long career spanning comedy and drama, from his early roles in The Santa Clause and 10 Things I Hate About You to his starring role as a math genius in Numb3rs and, more recently, a supporting turn in Oppenheimer.
Davionte “GaTa” Ganter
Initially known as rapper Lil Dicky’s real-life hype man, GaTa became a breakout star in Dave, where he plays a fictionalized version of himself, bringing humor and vulnerability to the role.
Ego Nwodim
A standout cast member on Saturday Night Live since 2018, Ego Nwodim has also appeared in comedies like Brockmire and Shrill, showcasing her sharp comedic delivery and knack for satire.
Jason Ritter
Jason Ritter has worked steadily in television. He has notable roles in Parenthood, where he played a caring teacher in a complicated romance, and Gravity Falls, where he voiced the adventurous Dipper Pines.
Related: Alan Cumming Is the ‘Worst’ at Keeping Secrets — So the ‘Traitors’ Host Is Ready to Spill (Exclusive)
John Cho
John Cho first rose to fame with Harold & Kumar Go to White Castle. He later transitioned into action and drama with Star Trek and Searching, where he played a father desperately using technology to find his missing daughter.
Justin Theroux
Justin Theroux has balanced indie films like Mulholland Drive with major projects like The Leftovers, where he played the emotionally tortured lead, and American Psycho, where he had a memorable supporting turn.
Patti Harrison
A comedian with a sharp and surreal sense of humor, Patti Harrison has appeared in I Think You Should Leave and Together Together, bringing her offbeat comedic style to both absurd sketches and heartfelt indie films.
Sam Richardson
Sam Richardson became known for his role as the lovable Richard Splett in Veep before taking on leading roles in The Afterparty and Detroiters, where he blended his natural comedic charm with sharp writing.
Simon Rex
Once known for his comedic roles in Scary Movie 3 and What I Like About You, Simon Rex reinvented his career with his acclaimed performance in Red Rocket, a drama about a washed-up former adult film star looking for a second chance.
Lauren Tom
From The Joy Luck Club to Futurama, Lauren Tom has proven her versatility across live-action and animation.
Lili Taylor
A mainstay in indie films and psychological thrillers, Lili Taylor knows how to bring depth and complexity to every role. Her most recent roles include Outer Ranger and Manhunt.
David Alan Grier
A legend of comedy and drama alike, David Alan Grier has tackled everything from sketch comedy to Broadway. He’s most known for roles such on Joe Pickett, St. Denis Medical and The Patient.
Natasha Leggero
Stand-up comedian, actress, and all-around scene-stealer, Natasha Leggero is known for her sharp wit and comedic timing in shows such as He’s Just Not That Into You and Another Period.
Sherry Cola
After stealing scenes in Joy Ride and Good Trouble, Sherry Cola is taking her talents to Poker Face Season 2.
Kevin Corrigan
A familiar face in crime dramas like The Departed and The Get Down, Kevin Corrigan knows his way around a gritty mystery.
Ben Marshall
Best known as one-third of the comedy trio Please Don’t Destroy on Saturday Night Live, Ben Marshall is making the jump from sketch comedy to crime-solving.
Kathrine Narducci
A veteran of The Sopranos and Euphoria, Kathrine Narducci is no stranger to playing tough, no-nonsense characters.
Next, New Clues and Every Revealed Cast Member of Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery
