10 Discontinued Childhood Candies You Would Probably Pay a Premium for Today

It’s no secret that even your favorite candy isn’t safe from being discontinued. The unfortunate reality is that if a product is underperforming or simply not meeting consumer expectations, the company behind it can quickly pull the plug at any time. Over the years, we’ve seen countless sweets quietly disappear from store shelves, leaving us all wishing we had stocked up while we still had the chance.

From limited-time releases and seasonal creations to big marketing swings and a few epic flops mixed in, the candy business is a revolving door of cult favorites, new arrivals and nostalgic reboots alike. And while some discontinued treats have eventually found their way back to store shelves in one form or another, plenty of others remain nothing more than beloved childhood memories.

🍳 SIGN UP to get delicious recipes, handy kitchen hacks & fun food news in our daily Pop Kitchen newsletter 🍳

Whether you remember the vibrant commercials advertising your favorite candy in the ’90s or still find yourself searching for that obscure early-2000s favorite, chances are you’d pay a pretty penny to relive the experience one more time. In honor of the fallen soldiers of candy’s past, we put together a list of 10 discontinued childhood candies you’d probably pay a premium for today. Follow along to see which ones made the cut, and let us know which of your favorites we might have missed!

Discontinued Childhood Candies

Two things to remember when it comes to your favorite candy: 1. Stock up while you still have the chance, and 2. Try not to get too attached. After all, you never know when your favorite sweet treat will quietly disappear, so it’s better to accept the possibility now than feel totally blindsided when it does.

1. Butterfinger BB’s

Introduced in the early ’90s and on shelves through the early 2000s, Butterfinger BB’s offered fans the same crispy, peanut buttery center of the popular candy bar but in a small, spherical form. Cemented in pop culture by memorable Simpsons advertising campaigns, Butterfinger BB’s eventually disappeared from shelves in 2006 with no explanation from Nestlé, but not without fans petitioning for its return — many still to this day.

2. Hershey’s Kissables

Debuting in the mid-2000s, Hershey’s Kissables have been sorely missed since being pulled from shelves. Taking the classic Hershey’s Kiss and giving it a smaller shape with a colorful candy shell, they were a lot like M&M’s but with the classic Hershey’s flavor. Over its short tenure, Hershey’s Kissables became a candy aisle staple, only to be abruptly discontinued in 2009 after a recipe change altered the flavor and texture that made them so popular in the first place.

3. Wonka Bar

About as memorable as candy can get, the Wonka Bar was a real-life version of the famous chocolate bar from Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory, with several iterations existing over the years. While the movie franchise it was modeled after has stood the test of time, Wonka Bars were eventually pulled from shelves after issues with the recipe caused the bars to melt too easily. Although Nestlé revived the brand with new variations, it never truly experienced the success of other competing chocolate bars and disappeared entirely by 2014.

4. Fruit Stripe Gum

Hailing from the 1960s yet extremely popular among kids through the ’90s and early 2000s, Fruit Stripe Gum was a childhood favorite for generations. Known for its colorful packaging and zebra mascot, it offered a mix of short-lived bursts of flavors and existed as a fun alternative to other leading gum brands. While Fruit Stripe certainly experienced decades of success, it was eventually discontinued in 2024 because of shifting consumer preferences, due in part to the flavor simply not lasting very long.

5. Shock Tarts

View this post on Instagram

A memorable sour snack from the ’90s and early 2000s, Shock Tarts came in a slender paper tube filled with tart, colorful candies shaped like small pucks, as well as smaller-count pouches similar to other bagged candies. After experiencing multiple name changes over the years, including Shockers and SweeTarts Chewy Sours, the original Shock Tarts quietly disappeared from shelves despite never technically being discontinued. 

Related: 15 Discontinued Fast-Food Burgers We Are Still Begging Them to Bring Back

6. Shark Bites

A staple in childhood lunchboxes across the country, Shark Bites captured the excitement of being a kid with colorful gummy sharks packed into a travel-friendly pouch. Backed by memorable cartoon commercials and the tagline “you gotta eat them before they eat you,” Shark Bites were eventually discontinued after General Mills changed the recipe to remove artificial flavors and colors. Unfortunately, the change eliminated the chalky texture the candy was known for and removed the famous “Great White” shark piece, leaving many fans disappointed with the new version.

7. Nestlé Wonder Ball

Introduced in the mid-’90s, Nestlé Magic Ball was a hollow chocolate ball with a small toy hidden inside. After concerns over the embedded toys potentially posing a choking hazard and legal issues surrounding nonfood items inside candy, Nestlé eventually pulled the treat from shelves in 1997. Years later, the Magic Ball returned as Wonder Ball with candy pieces inside instead of toys, but after a short run, it disappeared again when Nestlé sold the brand to Frankford Candy in 2004.

8. Altoids Sours

A sour spin on the classic Altoids brand, Altoids Sours were a tart, fruit-flavored hard candy sold in the brand’s signature round metal tins. Introduced in 2001 and discontinued in 2010, the candy became a cult favorite thanks to its enticing sour coating and unique balance of sweet and fruity flavors. Years later, the candy returned under the name Retro Sours, giving fans another chance to enjoy a similar version of the nostalgic treat.

9. Baja California Starburst

Created as a limited-edition flavor in the late 2000s, Baja California Starburst brought a tropical twist to the popular taffy candy with flavors like Dragon Fruit, Limon, Strawberry Watermelon and Aztec Punch. Complete with a hilarious commercial campaign and a short run on shelves, the nostalgic candy quickly earned a cult following, only to disappear after its limited promotional run came to an end.

10. Dweebs

The lesser-known sibling of the fan-favorite Nerds candy, Dweebs delivered a similar crunchy candy experience with a different shape and texture entirely. Released under the Wonka brand in the ’90s, Dweebs never reached the same level of popularity as some of its competitors. Still, fans who remember them would likely jump at the opportunity to purchase them again, making a comeback something many would welcome.

Much like all of our favorite foods, our favorite candies do a lot more than simply satisfy a sweet tooth. They evoke core childhood memories that stick with us long after the candy itself disappears, making any comeback one worth dreaming about. 

While the candies above certainly hold a special place in many fans’ lives, they’re also a reminder that even the best creations aren’t safe from the chopping block. That said, nothing is impossible, and with the right push from fans online, you never know what sweet treat might make a comeback in the years ahead.

Related: 9 Discontinued Trader Joe’s Frozen Meals Shoppers Are Still Mourning