Apple Watch Series 11 review: stuck in the middle Canada reviews

No one is going to wax lyrical about the Apple Watch Series 11. Not because it’s a bad smartwatch — it’s a great smartwatch, actually. There’s just nothing that makes it feel special this year. Alas, the $399 Series 11 is the middle child of Apple Watches.

It’s not the Series 11’s fault that the entry-level Apple Watch SE 3 got a major glow-up. It can’t help that the Apple Watch Ultra 3 gets everything the Series 11 has plus satellite connectivity. But there’s little to mask the fact that this watch doesn’t offer much more than the entry-level SE 3. You’re mostly paying extra for a bit of polish.

Hardware-wise, the Series 11 is nearly identical to its predecessor, but it has a redesigned dual antennae for 5G connectivity, a bigger battery, and a more scratch-resistant display. That’s about it. The smartest updates come in watchOS 26 — and none of those are exclusive to this watch.

Even so, there’s value in being a dependable workhorse. For certain folks, the Series 11 is still the best option over the new SE 3 or the Ultra. And that’s going to boil down to three factors: battery life, health, and comfort.

The significance of 24 hours

Since the first Apple Watch launched in 2015, Apple has never strayed from its “all-day” 18-hour battery life estimate. This year, for the first time ever, a watch has an estimated 24 hours on a single charge. It’s the single-most practical and important update for the Series 11.

Garmin lovers will scoff. After all, they measure battery life not in hours, but in weeks and months. But Apple has historically been ultraconservative with its battery estimates. For years, I’ve routinely gotten at least 24 hours on a single charge with Series watches. This year, the Series 11 has a bigger battery than previous models. The 42mm Series 11 gets a roughly 9 percent bump in capacity, while the 46mm gets an 11 percent increase. This, combined with a more power-efficient 5G modem, factors into why Apple felt confident to increase the estimate. But if you were hoping that this meant 36 to 40 hours on a single charge, the disappointing news is I’ve only seen a modest bump in my testing year-over-year.

Here’s what my first 48 hours with the Series 11 looked like. I took it off the charger at 10:30AM with 100 percent battery. I proceeded to have a busy day with several notifications, the always-on display enabled, and a lot of futzing around to play with new features in watchOS 26. I didn’t stick it onto a charger until a full 28 hours later, with roughly 8 percent battery left. A 25-minute charging session brought that back up to 62 percent, and then I went for a 31-minute run, which brought it back down to 46 percent. I went about the rest of my day, slept an entire night, and when I woke up around the 45-hour mark, I had 12 percent left.

These are similar numbers to what I got on the Series 10. The main difference is that I feel a bit more confident that I’ll still have charge when I wake up the next day. That wasn’t always true with the Series 10. Quite a few times during long-term testing, I’d wake up with a dead watch and incomplete sleep data.

Although I wouldn’t call this mind-blowing, battery remains an area where the Series 11 has a slight edge over the SE 3. You can read about my experience with the SE 3’s battery here, but the gist is that you can feel the difference between fast charging and 24-hour battery versus fast charging with 18-hour battery. I had to baby the SE 3’s battery a bit more than the Series 11.

This matters because if you map out which Apple Watch has which features, the Series 11 is clearly positioned as the “health watch.” And while Apple leads on advanced health detection features, it needs to catch up on sleep tracking. (It’s 2025, and it still can’t track naps!) You can’t have robust sleep tracking without a battery that reliably lasts at least 24 hours. So is it any coincidence that Apple is finally adding a Sleep Score (more on that below) in the year it improves battery life? I think not.

Better battery life means more possibilities outside of sleep tracking, too. For instance, Apple can offer better 5G connectivity for faster downloads and greater cellular coverage now that upgrading from LTE won’t automatically mean burning through the watch’s battery. I’ll dive deeper into 5G performance in my forthcoming Ultra 3 review, but unless you’re a heavy cellular user, the improvements here don’t dramatically change what the watch was already capable of.

The main reason you’d get the Series 11 over the SE 3 or Ultra 3 is because health tracking — not fitness tracking — is your primary concern in a smartwatch. If fitness is your top priority, the Ultra’s brighter and bigger screen, dual-frequency GPS, and rugged durability make more sense. The second reason to opt for the Series 11 is if you want something lightweight with the biggest possible screen without feeling like there’s a hulking brick on your wrist. That’s the Series 11 to a T.

Comfort-wise, this year’s model has the same dimensions as the Series 10, measuring 9.7mm thick with either a 42mm or 46mm case. The bezels are much thinner than the SE 3, with the display about 25 to 30 percent bigger, and it’s still 30 percent thinner than the Ultra 3. For older users or people with more petite wrists, this is a much more wearable design that doesn’t strain the eyes. (And if you want a keyboard to send messages more easily, that’s something the SE 3’s smaller screen can’t accommodate.)

On the health front, you get every available feature, but again, neither the FDA-cleared hypertension notifications nor the shiny new Sleep Score is exclusive to the Series 11. Older watches like the Series 9, 10, and Ultra 2 will also get hypertension notifications. Any watch that supports watchOS 26 will get Sleep Score, including the SE 3.

I can’t comment on hypertension notifications yet. It got FDA clearance last Friday, requires 14 days’ worth of data in a 30-day period, and it only just rolled out yesterday. What I can tell you now is that the feature utilizes the existing optical heart rate sensor without first needing to calibrate with a blood pressure cuff. The feature is based on data from 100,000 study participants, and there’s a validation paper you can read that goes into more depth. The gist is that instead of giving you exact blood pressure readings, it searches your heart data to see if there are patterns correlated with hypertension. If yes, then you’ll get an alert notifying you to check in with your doctor. We’ll have to report back once we’ve had more time to test, but this has massive potential as a health screening tool. Apple said in its keynote that it expects to detect 1 million cases over the next year.

What is available right now is the new Sleep Score, which is comprised of 100 points across three categories. You can earn up to 50 points for duration, where seven to eight hours is the ideal target. A consistent bedtime counts for up to an additional 30 points, while the last 20 points take into account how often and how long your sleep is interrupted. The way the data is presented is intuitive, and it smartly takes into consideration travel between time zones.

It’s not a unique metric. Fitbit, Garmin, Eight Sleep, and Oura have had sleep scores for years. However, I appreciate that Apple’s version gives more weight to factors within your control (duration and consistency) rather than sleep stage quality or biometrics. That creates more actionable insights than scores that include factors you have no control over. Conversely, it also means that most scores won’t be a surprise. On a night where I slept only two hours, I received an abysmal score of 23. I got a 93 on a night where I slept 7 hours, went to bed early, and only had six minutes of interrupted sleep. Still, I can see this being helpful if you’d rather focus on what you can control in improving your sleep habits.

Just as the health features are not exclusive to the Series 11, neither are the software updates in watchOS 26. I’ve been using the watchOS 26 beta since June, and I stand by what I said in my preview: the best updates are the revamped Smart Stack and the wrist-flick gesture.

Specifically, the Smart Stack menu subtly nudges you toward useful widgets when you need them. It’s always done this, but it’s a bit more noticeable now that there’s a tiny icon that pops up on your watchface to flag your attention. For example, if your phone camera is open, you’ll see a tiny camera icon on your watch. You can then use the double tap gesture to bring up the Smart Stack and open the remote. Meanwhile, the wrist-flick gesture is an extension of double tap. All you have to do is flick your wrist away from you to dismiss a notification, alarm, timer — you name it. Altogether, it’s easier than ever to use the Apple Watch one-handed, and that feels like a massive step forward.

Here are some other stray observations about watchOS 26:

A weird, in-between watch

The Series 11 is in a weird place. Most of what makes it great can be found on other Apple Watches, so there’s nothing that makes it truly stand out. Perhaps I’d be singing a different tune if the battery improvements were massive, but I suspect most Series 9 and 10 users would only get a few more hours with regular usage. Unless your current watch is broken, there’s little reason for people who prefer Series watches to upgrade.

For Apple Watch newbies or folks who aren’t convinced by smartwatches, the SE 3 is the more obvious, cost-effective choice. For people who want the best of the best, I could craft a 15-page PowerPoint extolling the Series 11’s best qualities, and they’d still buy an Ultra. For people who just want a slightly nicer Apple Watch? I guess that’s the Series 11.

That doesn’t make the Series 11 a bad product. It has just reached the point where it feels like the default, and default choices aren’t exciting. If you’ve held onto a Series 5 or a Series 6, you’re more likely to appreciate how the incremental improvements have added up to a better experience over time. But if you’re content with your perfectly functioning Series 7 or later? This is a year where I’d prioritize upgrading my phone or AirPods instead.