1983 Power Ballad, Originally Over 7 Minutes Long, Became a No. 1 Hit Twice

In 1983, Bonnie Tyler recorded a song so long that she worried radio stations would never play it.

That song was “Total Eclipse of the Heart.”

Written and produced by Jim Steinman, the dramatic power ballad originally ran 7 minutes and 2 seconds. Tyler later recalled in an interview with The Guardian that she wrote to a friend after recording it, “I recorded an incredible song today. The trouble is, it’s so long, I don’t think anybody will ever play it.”

To make it more radio-friendly, the track was edited down to about four and a half minutes. The shorter version was released as a single, but listeners quickly embraced the song’s larger-than-life sound and emotional intensity.

The gamble paid off in a big way.

“Total Eclipse of the Heart” spent four weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100, becoming Tyler’s biggest career hit. The song also topped charts around the world and went on to sell millions of copies.

But its chart story didn’t end there.

More than a decade later, British singer Nicki French released a dance-pop remake of “Total Eclipse of the Heart.” The cover became a major hit in its own right, reaching No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100 and climbing all the way to No. 1 on Billboard’s Top 40/Mainstream chart.

That rare feat made “Total Eclipse of the Heart” one of the relatively small number of songs to reach No. 1 twice through different hit versions.

The song’s origin story is almost as dramatic as the recording itself.

Steinman later revealed in an interview with Playbill that he originally conceived the song as a “vampire love song” while working on a prospective musical adaptation of the classic horror filmNosferatu. According to the songwriter, the working title was “Vampires in Love,” and traces of that dark inspiration remained in the finished lyrics.

Tyler immediately knew she had something special when Steinman played the song for her in New York.

“He played the grand piano while Rory Dodd sang Total Eclipse of the Heart to me,” Tyler told The Guardian. “I understood immediately what an incredible song it was.”

More than four decades after its release, the song continues to find new audiences.

“Total Eclipse of the Heart” has surpassed one billion streams on Spotify and its iconic music video has also crossed the one-billion-view mark on YouTube. The track regularly experiences renewed popularity during solar eclipses, including a major resurgence during the 2024 eclipse that sent it back up multiple digital sales charts.

For a song that Tyler once feared was too long for radio, “Total Eclipse of the Heart” has proven to have remarkable staying power.

Related: One of Rock’s Most Distinctive Voices Turns 75 Today