U.S. Senator Mitch McConnell sits with his wife, former U.S. secretary of labor Elaine Chao, while holding what appears to be the July 12 sports section of the Washington Post in a photograph released by his office on Sunday.Office of Senator Mitch McConnel/Reuters
When Kentucky Senator Mitch McConnell was taken by ambulance to a Washington hospital on June 14, no one would say why. Nearly a month passed, and no reason materialized.
Mr. McConnell’s office provided few updates on his condition. Last Tuesday, several Republican colleagues released similarly worded statements about the “lengthy” conversations they’d recently had with their “old friend.”
It did little to quash the fevered online rumours that Mr. McConnell was incapacitated or brain dead or actually dead. An exasperated Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear took to social media Saturday, urging Mr. McConnell to “end the crazy speculation. Just tell us what’s going on.”
The next evening, he did, posting a statement to Facebook revealing that a fall at home had led to his hospitalization, then a bout of pneumonia had extended his stay.
“Folks of my generation often hesitate to share the vulnerability that comes with growing older,” the 84-year-old wrote by way of explanation for his long public silence. He included a photo of himself at a rehab centre, smiling in a button-down and jeans, alongside his wife, Elaine Chao. He clutched a copy of Sunday’s The Washington Post, angled to face the camera.
The internet wasn’t exactly convinced.
Graham death, McConnell absence to weigh on U.S. Congress as it returns from break
Posters quickly pounced on what they claimed were the photo’s telltale signs of AI. Some, like Mark Fitzpatrick – who lost the Republican primary for Idaho governor in May – zeroed in on the blurriness of the paper’s headlines and inconsistencies in the senator’s skin tone. Others commented on Mr. McConnell’s Facebook page that something seemed off with the walls.
The doorframe behind Ms. Chao’s shoulder “curves inward like a banana,” one wrote, chalking it up to the fact AI image generators have “no concept of structural geometry.”
Despite such confident assertions, there’s nothing concrete to suggest the photo is the work of an AI tool. (Mr. McConnell’s office did not respond to The Globe and Mail’s request for comment.) But it isn’t surprising that so many people would jump to this conclusion. Even leading deepfake experts are struggling to distinguish the real from the fake on the internet. AI image generators have progressed well beyond old goofs such as extra fingers and weird shading.
Still, this particular image of Mr. McConnell – with its conspicuous staging and newspaper prop – feels strangely out of place. The proof-of-life photo is not a hallmark of liberal democracies. As PR moves go, it’s a tactic of authoritarian regimes.
Cuban leader Fidel Castro liked to release these sorts of photos to quell rumours of his demise. In 2006, after a weeks-long hospitalization, he appeared in an Adidas tracksuit gripping the front page of Granma, the Cuban Communist Party’s newspaper. In 2012, after reports of a massive stroke, he showed up on a farm looking at Granma from beneath a giant straw hat.
McConnell breaks weeks of silence, reveals fall as reason for hospitalization
In 2013, Venezuelan president Hugo Chávez borrowed from Castro’s playbook, reading the paper with his daughters while receiving cancer treatment.
But this is 2026, and outspoken MAGA figures are insisting a photo just won’t cut it – perhaps because a debunked image of Mr. McConnell holding the Post’s front page in his pyjamas already circulated widely last week. They’re demanding to see a proof-of-life video instead.
“How come Mitch McConnell’s staff won’t release a video of him?” far-right activist Laura Loomer posted on X. “I call BS.”
Fox News contributor and former Utah Republican representative Jason Chaffetz echoed that call. “Let’s see you say it,” he wrote on X, under a story about Mr. McConnell’s Facebook statement. “A written statement is far different than saying it on camera.”
The trouble is that it’s become every bit as easy to fake a video, and by Monday all manner of reasonably convincing AI-generated McConnells were making the social-media rounds. One leapt out of bed and performed a little breakdancing, much to his AI wife’s delight. Another ripped off his button-down and did his best impression of RFK Jr., bench-pressing shirtless in jeans.
For his part, President Donald Trump – never one to shy away from conspiracy theories or AI-generated memes – is staying above the fray. On Air Force One over the weekend, reporters asked him what he knew about Mr. McConnell’s condition. “I have no idea how he’s doing,” Mr. Trump replied.
