Coffee Mate Fans Rejoice as Hit Creamer Becomes Permanent: 'We Heard Ya Loud and Clear'

Coffee mate is starting 2026 on the right foot—it’s adding a fan-favorite creamer flavor to its permanent lineup.

To be fair, the popular creamer brand ended 2025 on a high note, too, releasing a Harry Potter collaboration followed by more zero-sugar options (most notably a Birthday Cake Creamer) after fans demanded it. And it looks like the brand is continuing to listen to customers, revealing in a social media post that it would be making one of its most requested limited-time flavors available year-round for the foreseeable future.

So, if you were among the cohorts of customers begging for Coffee mate’s Nestlé Toll House Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie creamer to hang out forever, the day has finally come.

Coffee mate Makes NestléToll House Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie Creamer A Permanent Flavor

The news has been a long time coming, with calls for the chocolate chip cookie-inspired creamer to be made permanent since its initial debut in August 2022.

“We heard ya loud and clear,” the brand wrote in an Instagram post shared on Friday, Jan. 23. “Coffee mate Nestle Toll House Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie flavored creamer is now available year-round!”

The once-limited-time flavor is a non-dairy, gluten-free, cholesterol-free creamer offering a “smooth and velvety” and “rich, warm flavor that transforms every drinking experience,” according to an official description. It can turn any cup of joe into a “delicious cup of cookie-flavored perfection,” and fans have given it “5 out of 5 stars.”

Related: Coffee Mate Fans Are ‘So Excited’ About New Cold Foam Flavor Spotted in Stores: ‘Here I Come’

View this post on Instagram

“@coffeemate and THIS is why I’m loyal to yall!!!!” one ecstatic fan shared in response to the news.

“I’ve been manifesting this for years now i can’t believe this is finally happening omg!!,” a second wrote, to which the brand joked: “proof manifestation works ✨.”

“This is extraordinary news fam,” another cheered.

“Now we need it zero sugar !” someone else suggested, before a different fan chimed in, squealing, “Thank youuuuu!! 🍪.”

“LETS GOOOOOOOOOO,” another exclaimed.

“The BEST news 😍❤️,” one more declared.

While the company didn’t shout out any specific retailers, we expect it to be available at stores nationwide that carry other offers from the brand (such as Walmart, Kroger, ShopRite, Stop & Shop, HEB, Winn-Dixie, Shaw’s, etc.) in 32-ounce containers (prices may vary) in the coming weeks if not already. Shoppers looking to restock are encouraged to use the product locator to find a store near them.

As for that matching Cold Foam creamer…it’s currently unclear whether it’s also heading out permanently, but fans can certainly hope for the best and prepare for the worst (it remaining a limited-time offer).

Next: Planet Oat Debuts Two New First-Of-Its-Kind Creamers