Shark Tank has a way of putting certain food brands on your radar—and Daisy Cakes is one brand that still resonates 15 years later. The Southern-style cake company, founded by Kim Nelson, built its pitch around scratch-made family recipes, traditional techniques, and desserts that look like they came straight out of grandma’s kitchen rather than a commercial bakery.
That approach is a big part of the brand’s appeal. Daisy Cakes focuses on classic flavors—like coconut, carrot, chocolate and red velvet—made in small batches and shipped nationwide. The cakes are fully frosted, layered, and designed to feel homemade, which is not always easy to pull off when something has to survive shipping.
😋😋SIGN UP to get delicious recipes, handy kitchen hacks & more in our daily Pop Kitchen newsletter🍳🍔
Of course, that’s also where the hesitation comes in. Ordering a cake online is a bit of a gamble. Between the price, the potential for damage during delivery and the question of whether it will actually taste as good as it looks, expectations can be high, and results can vary.
I finally got my hands on one to see how it holds up outside the spotlight—and whether it’s worth the price once it’s on your table.
What Is Special About Daisy Cakes?
Courtesy Daisy Cakes
What sets Daisy Cakes apart is its focus on traditional Southern-style baking, with a heavy emphasis on scratch-made methods and familiar flavors. Instead of chasing trends or over-the-top combinations, the brand sticks to classics that feel nostalgic and comforting.
Each cake is layered and frosted, with an emphasis on a homemade look rather than a polished, bakery-case finish. That slightly imperfect appearance is intentional—it’s meant to mirror the kind of cakes you’d expect made by hand from a family recipe, rather than a mass-produced dessert.
Another key difference is how the cakes are handled for shipping. Rather than trying to deliver them fresh and risking damage, Daisy Cakes sends them frozen, packed with dry ice. This helps preserve structure and texture during transit, which is critical for a product that has to travel long distances.
Related: High Poppi Performance! How Did ‘Shark Tank’ Guest Allison Ellsworth Make Her Soda Money?
What Happened to Daisy Cakes After Shark Tank?
Daisy Cakes gained national attention after appearing on Shark Tank (season 2, episode 5), where Nelson struck a deal with Barbara Corcoran. The exposure helped transform the business from a small, homegrown operation into a recognizable name in the mail-order dessert space.
Since then, the brand has continued to grow while sticking to its core identity. It has expanded its online presence and built a steady following, especially around holidays when desserts are in high demand and time is scarce.
That staying power is notable. Many food brands that have appeared on Shark Tank fade after the initial buzz, but Daisy Cakes has maintained visibility, in part because it leans into a clear identity rather than constantly reinventing itself.
Related: Every Shark on ‘Shark Tank’ Ranked by Net Worth in 2026
What Can You Order From Daisy Cakes?
Courtesy Daisy Cakes
The menu centers on classic cake flavors: lemon, coconut, chocolate, carrot, and red velvet, forming the backbone of the lineup. There are also seasonal and specialty offerings that vary with the time of year, giving returning customers something new to try.
Cakes are sold whole rather than by the slice, and they are not inexpensive. However, pricing reflects the handmade quality and the shipped nature of the product. Most standard four-layer cakes are priced at $69.95, with gluten-free, vegan, and “Happy Birthday” versions running about $10 more. Half-and-half cakes come in slightly higher at $74.95.
It’s positioned as a premium, shipped dessert—more in line with a gift or special-occasion purchase than something you’d order on a whim. The brand also offers a Cake of the Month Club that delivers rotating flavors on a recurring basis for those who want to make it a more regular indulgence.
Shipping plays a major role in the experience. Cakes are sent frozen to hold up in transit, but that ends up being a benefit, since it lets you slice off only what you need and thaw it in smaller portions. Each piece only takes a couple of hours to thaw, making it easy to plan around.
I Tried Daisy Cakes—Here’s My Honest Review
Jim Hoffman
The first thing I noticed was the box’s weight—it’s heavy. Taking it out of the shipping package, the cake was still very much frozen, which felt like a good sign for something that had to travel.
I ordered the carrot cake, which the website lists as its No. 1 seller—and it also happens to be one of my all-time favorites.
Jim Hoffman
After letting it thaw and cutting into it, I was struck again by the size. This is a massive cake. It’s built with four layers, each about an inch thick, making it nearly impossible to serve “just a small slice.” Visually, it’s impressive. The cake is cleanly assembled and evenly frosted—but with a hand-finished look that feels closer to what you’d expect at a high-end restaurant or steakhouse than to a mail-order cake.
Jim Hoffman
The first bite delivers a strong hit of flavor. The cake itself is well-balanced, with the sweetness of the cream cheese frosting working nicely against the spiced, cinnamon-forward layers. Large pieces of shredded carrot are clearly visible throughout, along with whole golden raisins, which add both texture and bursts of sweetness.
Jim Hoffman
One of the things I look for in a carrot cake is moisture. Given that this one was shipped frozen and thawed at home, I expected it to be slightly drier than something fresh from a bakery or my own oven—but that wasn’t the case. It retained its moisture well and remained intact without crumbling. Overall, it’s a well-executed cake. At $69.95 for a standard cake—and more for specialty versions—it’s not an everyday purchase, but the size helps justify the cost. It feels better suited for a gathering or as a gift than a casual dessert. The website estimates 16 to 20 servings, but given how substantial each slice is, you could likely stretch that closer to 24 and still leave guests satisfied.
How to Order Daisy Cakes
Jim Hoffman
Daisy Cakes can be ordered directly through the company’s website, where you’ll find the full lineup of flavors along with seasonal offerings. Because the cakes are shipped frozen, it’s a good idea to plan ahead, especially if you’re ordering for a specific occasion.
Shipping timelines and availability can vary depending on demand, so checking delivery windows before placing an order is worth doing. Once it arrives, allowing time for the cake to thaw properly will help ensure you get the best possible texture and flavor.
For anyone who remembers seeing Daisy Cakes on Shark Tank and has been curious ever since, ordering one is a straightforward way to see how it holds up beyond the pitch—and whether it actually justifies the price once it’s on your table.
Related: 12 ‘Shark Tank’ Food Products at Costco to Buy in 2026
