Parade aims to feature only the best products and services. If you buy something via one of our links, we may earn a commission.
If you’ve ever applied concealer under your eyes and watched it migrate directly into every fine line within the hour, you’re not doing anything wrong—you’re just doing it the way you’ve always done it, without accounting for the fact that mature skin plays by completely different rules. Life!
Concealer is one of those products that can either make you look more awake and polished than you have any right to at 7 a.m., or it can draw a detailed map of every crease around your eyes by noon. The difference between those two outcomes isn’t really about which concealer you buy. It’s almost entirely about what you do before you apply it.
The under-eye area is genuinely one of the more demanding canvases in makeup. The skin there is thinner than anywhere else on the face, it moves constantly every time you blink or make an expression, and it loses moisture faster than the rest of your skin does.
Add the fact that most concealers contain water that evaporates throughout the day—taking the formula’s structure with it—and you start to understand why settling and creasing aren’t random. They’re physics. They’re going to happen unless you actively build a routine that works against them.
The good news is that the fix isn’t complicated, and it doesn’t require spending a fortune on new products. It mostly requires slowing down, doing a few minutes of prep and understanding a little bit about why your concealer does what it does.
For the specifics, we talked to Katie Mellinger, a celebrity makeup artist who has worked with Sofia Coppola, Maya Hawke, Emma Watson, Jamie Lee Curtis and Stephanie Beatriz, and she has expertise in mature skin application. What she’s shared is the kind of practical, no-nonsense advice that makes you want to completely redo your routine from scratch—in the best way.
Related: A Celebrity Makeup Artist Reveals if You Should Use Concealer or Foundation First (You Might Be Surprised!)
How To Apply Concealer on Mature Skin: Genius Trick from Makeup Artist
It’s all about less product, and more intention. Mellinger’s approach starts before the brush even touches your face: she puts a small amount of concealer on the back of her hand, swirls her brush in it to distribute the product evenly, then applies it in stippling motions rather than dragging or swiping.
“Less is always more, and you can build up slowly,” she tells Parade.
Her tool of choice is the BK Beauty Hot & Flashy A506 Concealer Brush, whose angled “kitten paw” shape lets her work precisely around the eye without losing sight of what she’s doing.
“You can keep the brush at an angle away from the eye so you can see exactly what you’re doing,” she explains. That level of control matters enormously when you’re working with a thin, delicate area where a little too much product in the wrong spot makes a visible difference.
Related: 15 Best Body Lotions for Aging Skin (Dermatologist Tested)
Where Should You Apply Concealer for a Lifting Effect?
Here’s where Mellinger offers a take that might surprise you: she doesn’t actually think concealer is the right tool for lifting. That’s more of a highlight and contour conversation, and on mature skin she’d address it with foundation rather than concealer.
Concealer is genuinely for coverage under the eye, and placement matters more than most people realize. “You will see the darkest spots run along the orbital bone, with the darkest point being on the lower inner corner,” she explains.
She concentrates the most product there and along the orbital bone, deliberately avoiding the area just beneath the center of the eye. Her focus is the hollow pocket on the inner orbital bone and the bottom outer edge. Applying concealer in a targeted way rather than flooding the entire under-eye area is one of the simplest changes that produces an immediate, noticeable improvement.
Related: 12 Best Night Creams for Women Over 50, According to Celebrity Makeup Artists
How Do You Prep Mature Under-Eye Skin Before Applying Concealer?
This is the step most people rush, and it’s the one that determines everything that comes after. Mellinger’s starting rule: wait at least five to ten minutes after skincare before touching concealer. The skin needs time to actually absorb what you’ve applied, or your concealer is going on top of a slippery surface and will move accordingly.
The counterintuitive part is what she says about eye cream. The rich, occlusive formulas most people use at night—the ones that feel most luxurious—are actually the enemy of concealer longevity. “I know this feels counter-intuitive,” she says, “but for makeup prep, you want to avoid the heavy, occlusive eye creams that you use at night. These tend to cause more slippage.”
Her preference for daytime makeup prep is a hydrating serum under the eye instead, followed by a primer on top once the serum has absorbed.
And if even that feels like too many steps, she has a simpler path: skip the eye cream entirely and use a hydrating primer as the single prep step. The e.l.f. Power Grip is her recommendation here because it contains both water and niacinamide, doing double duty as hydrator and primer in one.
Related: The 7 Best Concealers for Mature Skin, According to Celebrity Makeup Artists
Why Does Concealer Settle Into Fine Lines?
According to Mellinge, three things are happening all at once. First, any liquid formula naturally gets drawn into creases and grooves the same way water finds the lowest point of a surface.
Second, every blink and expression flexes the skin around the eye, which shifts and concentrates the concealer in the folds—”similar to how paint cracks on a surface that keeps moving,” she explains.
Third, most concealers contain water that evaporates throughout the day, and as it does, the formula loses its structure and the remaining product migrates directly into fine lines.
All three of these issues compound with age because the lines are more present and mature skin retains moisture less effectively. Understanding this is actually empowering because it tells you exactly what to work against. The more you know!
Related: 11 Best Eyeshadows for Mature Skin, According to Celebrity Makeup Artists
What Concealer Mistakes Should You Avoid Over 50?
The biggest one: reaching for more product when coverage isn’t landing the way you want it to. It feels like the logical fix, but it’s the opposite of what works. “The more product you use, the more product there is to pile into fine lines,” Mellinger says.
The right approach is to decide what level of coverage you actually need and then use the absolute minimum amount of the right product to get there. Restraint is the skill.
How Do You Keep Concealer From Creasing All Day?
Getty
Everything connects back to prep—the right primer, the right concealer formula and avoiding anything too occlusive under the eye. Setting powder helps, but Mellinger is emphatic about using the smallest possible amount with a very fluffy brush. More powder means more product to settle, which is the opposite of what you’re trying to accomplish.
The formula relationship between your primer and your concealer matters more than most people know. Water-based concealers need water-based primers. Silicone-based concealers need silicone-based primers. Mixing the two creates a compatibility problem that no amount of technique can fix.
Related: These Are the 15 Best Bronzers for Mature Skin, According to Beauty Experts
What Should Women Do Instead for More Defined, Flattering Results?
Mellinger’s three concealer picks each solve a different version of the problem, and knowing which one matches your routine makes all the difference.
For a natural finish with full prep, she loves Tower 28’s Swipe Concealer paired with the e.l.f. Power Grip Primer—water-based on water-based, applied after serum and a full wait time. If you want something more forgiving that doesn’t require flawless prep, IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye is her pick. It’s wax-based, which sidesteps the water evaporation issue entirely and is “dummy proof,” as she puts it—forgiving even when prep isn’t perfect, though she does recommend a light setting powder afterward given its luminous finish.
And if the whole multi-step process sounds like too much before 8 a.m., she has an answer for that too. “If all of this is just too overwhelming,” she says, “the best concealer out there is HAUS Labs Triclone Skin Tech Concealer.” Its silicone resin base self-sets seconds after blending, locking the formula in place before it has a chance to migrate—no setting powder required, no compatibility math, just a natural finish that stays put.
Her words: “You get a natural finish without the need for a setting powder.” That’s the dream.
Up Next:
Related: I Tried Summer Fridays’ Best-Selling Beauty Products for 30 Days—Here Are the 4 Favorites I’d Buy Again
Source:
- Katie Mellinger, celebrity makeup artist
