Canadian ReviewsCanadian Reviews
  • What’s On
  • Reviews
  • Digital World
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Trending
  • Web Stories
Trending Now

Are Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Engaged? Fans Spot 'Hidden Ring' in Viral Photo

25th Jul: Happy Gilmore 2 (2025), 1hr 57m [PG-13] (6/10)

George Santos now in prison for 7-year sentence

GPD’s monster Strix Halo handheld requires a battery ‘backpack’ or a 180W charger Canada reviews

Rick and Morty spinoff will follow Keith David’s President Curtis

Deanonymize Your Guests To Improve Guest Hospitality Experiences

Ozzy Osbourne Didn't Believe in Heaven or Hell

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Advertise
  • Contact us
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest Vimeo
Canadian ReviewsCanadian Reviews
  • What’s On
  • Reviews
  • Digital World
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • Trending
  • Web Stories
Newsletter
Canadian ReviewsCanadian Reviews
You are at:Home » When my parents were denied a tourist visa for a family vacation in Canada, it felt like history repeating itself | Canada Voices
Lifestyle

When my parents were denied a tourist visa for a family vacation in Canada, it felt like history repeating itself | Canada Voices

23 July 20255 Mins Read

Open this photo in gallery:

Illustration by Catherine Chan

First Person is a daily personal piece submitted by readers. Have a story to tell? See our guidelines at tgam.ca/essayguide.

This spring, I received a request to write a short piece on the Komagata Maru. I teach South Asian history, so the request made sense. The ill-fated ship had arrived in Vancouver on May 23, 1914, with 376 passengers from India, who lingered just off the coast for two months after being refused entry.

In the end, everyone but a handful were turned back as they did not fulfill a regulation from 1908 that prohibited people from landing in Canada if they had not travelled continuously from their native lands. Immigrants were also required to be in possession of $200.

The continuous journey requirement, an amendment to the Immigration Act, effectively stemmed new arrivals from Asia while disguising racist intent. When combined with the suspension of the sale of through tickets from India to Canada, the law ensured it was virtually impossible for South Asians to land here.

These legislative changes, which followed an infamous report suggesting that South Asians were incompatible with the Canadian climate and way of life and would therefore end up destitute, are now widely recognized as racist and discriminatory.

But I could not write that history piece as I was smarting from my own wounds over a refused entry. In mid-April, my parents in India were denied a tourist visa for a family vacation in British Columbia. While muttering to myself about history repeating itself, I did not believe my parents were in the same proverbial boat at all. The B.C. government had apologized for the Komagata Maru in 2008, as had then-prime minister Justin Trudeau in 2016.

Trudeau apologizes for ‘great injustice’ of Komagata Maru incident

I convinced myself that all I had to do was find unassailable evidence to disprove the two reasons cited to deny them entry to Canada for four weeks.

The refusal letter my parents received claimed they lacked the financial ability to vacation here. This is the modern-day version of the demand to show $200, except what is considered sufficient is now a mystery. Had my parents somehow failed to prove they could stay for free in my home?

The tellingly titled “generic denial letter” also stated that the officer did not believe my parents would leave at the end of their visit. I gathered more than a hundred pages of documents to dispel this suspicion.

I annotated documents detailing our collective financial history from both sides of the globe. $200 in pocket? Check.

Then I added evidence of a time-limited visit: return flights from Delhi to Vancouver, a ferry schedule to Salt Spring Island and hotel reservations in Vancouver to bookend the time on the island. I attached copies of previous passports and visas to Canada and elsewhere. The entry and exit stamps proved they never overstayed. Their four trips to Canada since 2007 averaged out to exactly four weeks per visit.

And then there was the evidence of the comfortable life they would return to. Evidence of intent to return? Check.

I spent hours shrinking the hundreds of pages because, in a haunting reminder of the engineered impossibility of the demands for a continuous journey, the website only allowed five files of 2 MB each.

I felt optimistic about the quantum of evidence.

My parents started packing their bags.

Within weeks, they were refused a tourist visa for a second time. The officer still did not believe they would leave Canada.

This time I was broken. I had no papers left to show.

The truth is, my parents have little desire to undertake this very long journey, let alone to linger in Canada.

I had worked hard to convince them to make this trip because I would love for them to spend time in my home. Because my six-year-old wants to play with them outside of a phone screen. Because my partner wants them to see the island that is his childhood home.

It is true that, unlike the passengers on the Komagata Maru who’d boarded a ship to immigrate to Canada only to be returned to India to face bullets, my parents have merely been deprived of a family vacation.

As for me, I have been rendered destitute after all. I might be a naturalized citizen of Canada, but I do not belong. I made myself a home here but failed to mount the evidence required to allow my parents to visit it.

I have tried to tell myself that a chasm separates me, with the ledger of privileges I uploaded to the government website, and the fellow South Asians turned away from Canada’s shores more than a hundred years ago.

But I have learned that “sufficient evidence” is a moving target in a system where the rules have been perfected to disguise racism, and the reasons for keeping out Third World travellers are generic precisely to make room for discrimination without conceding the word’s negative connotations.

In 1914, we Canadians had an ostensibly race-neutral law that somehow mostly affected those of a certain hue, but then too there were some among us – of brown skin – who could land, to be cited as evidence of the innocence of the law itself.

In 2025, we remain haunted by that law, but we convince ourselves that the past is history. As I did too this spring, when I mistakenly believed that by refusing to dwell on the past, I could secure my present in Canada.

Ishita Pande lives in Kingston.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Reddit WhatsApp Telegram Email

Related Articles

Are Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Engaged? Fans Spot 'Hidden Ring' in Viral Photo

Lifestyle 25 July 2025

25th Jul: Happy Gilmore 2 (2025), 1hr 57m [PG-13] (6/10)

Lifestyle 25 July 2025

George Santos now in prison for 7-year sentence

Lifestyle 25 July 2025

Rick and Morty spinoff will follow Keith David’s President Curtis

Lifestyle 25 July 2025

Ozzy Osbourne Didn't Believe in Heaven or Hell

Lifestyle 25 July 2025

25th Jul: Mandala Murders (2025), 8 Episodes [TV-MA] (6/10)

Lifestyle 25 July 2025
Top Articles

OANDA Review – Low costs and no deposit requirements

28 April 2024341 Views

These Ontario employers were just ranked among best in Canada

17 July 2025227 Views

What Time Are the Tony Awards? How to Watch for Free

8 June 2025151 Views

Getting a taste of Maori culture in New Zealand’s overlooked Auckland | Canada Voices

12 July 2025127 Views
Demo
Don't Miss
Travel 25 July 2025

Deanonymize Your Guests To Improve Guest Hospitality Experiences

Deanonymize Your Guests To Improve Guest Hospitality Experiences – By Doug Kennedy – Image Credit…

Ozzy Osbourne Didn't Believe in Heaven or Hell

25th Jul: Mandala Murders (2025), 8 Episodes [TV-MA] (6/10)

Much Rewind launches on YouTube as archive of MuchMusic’s celebrity interviews, pop culture moments | Canada Voices

About Us
About Us

Canadian Reviews is your one-stop website for the latest Canadian trends and things to do, follow us now to get the news that matters to you.

Facebook X (Twitter) Pinterest YouTube WhatsApp
Our Picks

Are Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Engaged? Fans Spot 'Hidden Ring' in Viral Photo

25th Jul: Happy Gilmore 2 (2025), 1hr 57m [PG-13] (6/10)

George Santos now in prison for 7-year sentence

Most Popular

Why You Should Consider Investing with IC Markets

28 April 202422 Views

OANDA Review – Low costs and no deposit requirements

28 April 2024341 Views

LearnToTrade: A Comprehensive Look at the Controversial Trading School

28 April 202448 Views
© 2025 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of use
  • Advertise
  • Contact us

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.