The Bee Gees had already found fame, but this song gave them an American first.
Fifty-five years ago today, on Aug. 23, 1971, “How Can You Mend a Broken Heart” was sitting atop the Billboard Hot 100. Released that May as the lead single from the Bee Gees’ album Trafalgar, the soft rock ballad became the group’s first U.S. No. 1 hit. Billboard later ranked it as the No. 5 song of 1971.
The achievement came after a turbulent period for the group. Robin Gibb left the Bee Gees in 1969 following disagreements over which brother should sing lead. Barry and Maurice Gibb continued briefly as a duo before the group separated. By 1970, all three brothers had reunited, and Barry and Robin wrote “How Can You Mend a Broken Heart” during one of their first sessions back together.
Barry later reflected on how success had affected the brothers, saying, “Before we ever became famous were the best times of our lives. There was no competition; it didn’t matter who sang what.”
That history gave the song’s lyrics another layer of meaning. Rather than offering an easy answer to the title’s question, the brothers move through loneliness, regret and the struggle to understand how a once-happy relationship fell apart. Their controlled vocals and close harmonies keep the performance tender even as the words become more desperate.
The song was originally written with Andy Williams in mind as a potential singer. The Bee Gees ultimately recorded it themselves, but Williams later included his own version on his 1971 album You’ve Got a Friend. His smooth vocal style made the ballad a natural fit and showed how easily the Gibb brothers’ songwriting could move between soft rock and traditional pop.
“How Can You Mend a Broken Heart” also earned the Bee Gees a Grammy nomination for Best Pop Performance by a Duo or Group with Vocals. The group eventually collected five Grammys, scored nine No. 1 hits and entered the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame in 1997.
More than half a century later, the ballad remains a crucial part of that history. It was a song about repairing a broken bond, created just as the brothers were learning how to repair their own.
Related: 1965 Iconic Ballad, Covered by Linda Ronstadt, Is Still an Inspirational Hit 61 Years Later
